Hardwood vs Carpet: Which is Right for Your Space?

Mar 13, 2023
Hardwood vs Carpet Which is Right for Your Space

At first glance, the choice between hardwood floors or carpeting in your home looks tricky. Some parts of the hardwood vs carpet decision are based on preference, while others involve hard facts.

So let’s break it down. The decision process is fairly easy to simplify, and at Signature Hardwood Floors we’ve been supplying the right answers for thousands of customers with different flooring needs.  

Hardwood vs Carpet: Space and Room Considerations

Room size

Do you have large, spacious rooms that are attractive to the point where you want to show them off?

If so, you need hardwood floors. It’s worth paying a little extra to get them, especially when you consider the resale value hardwood floors will add to your home. You can also add some great design elements if you want to get creative.

Carpets can be a solid choice if you have smaller rooms, but hardwood wins the battle in this particular segment of hardwood vs carpet.

 Overall square footage

While room size is important, you should also need to consider the number of square feet you need to handle, especially if you’re on a budget.

Carpet can be a good way to go if you’re on a budget, but varying the types of hardwood floors you add on a room-by-room basis can give your home an even more unique look.

Hardwood vs Carpet: Durability and Installation

Installation issues

Carpet is probably the winner in this part of the hardwood vs carpet debate. In most instances, it can be installed in a day, and sometimes in a matter of hours. Keep in mind, though, that the extra time you allocate to install hardwood floors will pay off in all kinds of ways.


 This segment of the hardwood vs carpet debate is also a no-brainer. Hardwood floors are definitely more durable—they can actually last for over 50 years if they’re maintained, cleaned, and finished regularly.  

Some types of carpet are more durable than others, but hardwood floors win this part of the hardwood vs carpet debate hands down.  

Cleaning, Comfort, and Allergies


This is one of the closest categories in the hardwood vs carpet debate, but hardwood still comes out on top. Both choices are easy to clean, but you may have to buy a carpet cleaning machine for certain types of carpets.


While some people prefer the clean feel of walking on an attractive hardwood floor, carpet probably gets the nod in this particular hardwood vs carpet category. You can choose the thickness, fabrics, and material to minimize wear and tear and maximize comfort.


For some homeowners, allergies are a huge issue in the hardwood vs comfort debate, and once again hardwood wins hands down. Carpet traps dust that contains allergens, no matter how much you clean it. Hardwood floors don’t.

Use Signature Hardwood Floors to Make the Right Hardwood vs Carpet Call

If you need help with the hardwood vs carpet debate, Signature Hardwood Floors is the ultimate resource. We offer multiple types of flooring to meet your needs and we’ll match our flooring to your budget, too. The number to call is (410) 415-0755, or you can use this link to learn more or schedule a free in-home consultation.